The vegetable import ban policy in Botswana is not the right policy at the moment and here is why.
Crop production in Botswana is limited to small areas as only 3% of the country’s land is arable. This arable land is situated in the eastern and northern part of the country which poses a challenge to supply chain and logistics. The government is aware of the problem as it initially implemented the official policy of 1991 to secure food security through imports acknowledging that they are not self-sufficient and much of Botswana’s demand is met through imports. Why, abandon a policy that has been working? Were there any technologies used to improve productivity post 1991 and can the increase in productivity be measurable?
Agricultural performance in Botswana has been declining despite the introduction of new technologies designed to improve performance. The area of fallow land increased over the years due to degrading soil quality and inadequate rainfall. With climate change leading to increased temperatures and rainfall variability it is clear that increased crop production is less likely to be achieved in an arid country like Botswana.
The import ban will reduce imports from South Africa, but it is not clear if this will be matched by an equivalent increase in domestic vegetable production. Econsult Botswana in December 2024 reported that the impact of Botswana’s vegetable import ban led to a 24% increase in vegetable prices. This could be attributed to seasonal unavailability and low domestic supply which potentially reduce real income and further suppress the living standards of low income households.
With local producers relying heavily on protectionism for competitiveness it is unlikely that the import ban will remain effective in the long run and what happens when domestic supply is unable to keep up with demand? Vegetable smuggling is e on the rise as informal traders smuggle vegetables from neighbouring countries to avoid hefty prices and seasonal supply shortages. Vegetable consumption may likely decline as low supply increases prices and thus detrimental to the food security status of the country.
While you snooze, we think about non-tariff barriers. If Botswana matters in your life, say hello at info@xagta.com